Season One Episodes:
- Foreman: "You assaulted that man!"
- House: "Fine! I’ll never do it again."
- Foreman: "Yes you will!"
- — DNR
DNR is a 1st season episode of House which first aired on February 1, 2005. A famous musician with ALS loses all hope when he realizes he can no longer play his trumpet. However, House doubts the ALS diagnosis is correct and encourages Foreman to pursue an aggressive course of treatment. When House defies the patient’s “Do Not Resuscitate” order and is kept away from the patient, he still won’t let the matter drop.
Giles is taken to Princeton-Plainsboro. House asks to be assigned to the patient. He thinks the paralysis has an undiagnosed cause. Cuddy thinks the patient has only developed pneumonia. However, Foreman had previously worked with the patient's regular doctor, Marty Hamilton, and has already been assigned to the case.
Foreman takes charge of the team, but House isn't taking him seriously. House asks about the paralysis, but Foreman points to the ALS diagnosis. However, House points out there is no definitive diagnostic test for it, and it is incurable. House starts a differential anyway, but Foreman shoots down the proposal because no other possible cause fits. House points out it's a death sentence, but Foreman says that doesn't make it wrong.
Foreman goes to see the patient, and tells him the pneumonia is probably related to the ALS. The patient learns House is on his case, and the patient asks Foreman for House's opinion. Foreman disagrees with House, so the patient doesn't consent to an MRI. The patient also asks for a do not resuscitate order, or DNR. Foreman can't dissuade him.
Foreman tells House about the DNR. Foreman is treating the pneumonia with steroids, but House wants him to treat for other conditions. Foreman starts him on House's suggested treatment, but doesn't tell House or the patient.
The patient goes into respiratory arrest as the result of House's suggested treatment. House comes in and finds the team obeying the DNR order. House starts resuscitating him anyway. At that moment, the patient's agent comes in and asks what is going on.
The patient is put on a respirator. Foreman challenges House over his efforts to save the patient. House says the only reason the patient signed the DNR was because he thought he had ALS; if he doesn't, he wouldn't want to die. Foreman storms out. House starts a differential with Chase and Cameron. However, at that moment, House is served with a restraining order. House orders tests on the remaining blood, and asks Chase to do a lung biopsy and move the patient nearer the clinic so the restraining order will prevent him from having to work there.
Cuddy asks House if he needs a lawyer. She's upset, but she has set aside money for legal expenses and she's under budget and she sees no point arguing with House. However, she informs House that Marty Hamilton is flying in to take charge of the case.
House goes to court over the restraining order. House's lawyer argues that the patient can't be allowed to die because an assault complaint has been laid against House and the patient must be alive in order to testify. House tells Wilson he's only going through the process to buy time to diagnose the patient. House impresses the judge by pointing out clubbing in his fingers which indicates a heart condition and tells the judge to seek treatment. The judge turns out to have a family history of the disease, and rules in House's favor - the patient can't be taken off life support until House's trial. However, House admits to Wilson he was only guessing about the heart disease and saw no clubbing.
House goes back to Chase and Cameron to ask them to treat the patient. House does it himself in defiance of the court order. He runs into the patient's regular doctor. He tells the other doctor he's treating the patient for granulomatosis with polyangiitis (GPA). Foreman has a reunion with Dr. Hamilton. House points out they can't kill the patient, but Hamilton tells him they have dropped the charges.
They disconnect the patient from the respirator, but he starts breathing on his own. This proves it isn't GPA. House admits he was wrong - again.
The patient is stable, but one of his arms is now paralyzed. The progression of paralysis once again confirms ALS. Cameron suggests a stroke. House notes that the restraining order is no longer in place and goes to see the patient. He asks the patient to let him complete a diagnosis. The patient agrees to indulge House's obsession, but since he can't play music any more, he feels he has no reason to live. The patient points out that diagnosis is to House what music is to him. At that point, House takes him to get an MRI.
Foreman is talking to Dr. Hamilton. He's asked if he enjoys working with House and if he's in a serious relationship. He offers Foreman a partnership at three times his current salary.
Foreman points out to his colleagues that he has a contract, but they tell him House wouldn't care if he left. At that moment, Chase finds evidence of a stroke, explaining the paralysis in the arm, but not the legs. They want to treat the patient with blood thinners, despite the risk of bleeding in his lungs, but the patient refuses. Foreman suggests directly removing the clot and the patient agrees because it won't affect his lungs. They do the procedure to remove the clot successfully.
Foreman goes to House about the difference between House and Dr. Hamilton. House isn't impressed with Hamilton's faked humility, but Foreman points out House has been wrong on every step of this case.
The patient's arm function improves. Dr. Hamilton congratulates House to House's annoyance, but at that moment the patient reports feeling in his leg.
House is glad the patient is getting better, but they have no idea why. Dr. Hamilton figures it is the previous treatment, but Foreman is skeptical. One treatment is definitely working, but they can't figure out which one. They have to try each medication one at a time, so they have to convince the patient's doctor to discontinue his ongoing treatment. However, Dr. Hamilton wants to know what medications House has been using. The patient has started getting worse. House orders another MRI and steroids.
Cameron points out that House would have to either let Foreman out of his contract to work for Dr. Hamilton or admit he needs him. Meanwhile, House is talking to Foreman about the job offer, telling him that if he thinks Dr. Hamilton is a better doctor, he should go and work for him.
The new MRI shows a malformed blood vessel compressing the spine, but previous radiology showed nothing. It turns out the abnormality's inflammation hid it from x-rays until they got the swelling down with the steroids. If they remove it, he will recover the use of his legs.
The patient is given surgery and regains the feeling in his legs. After physiotherapy, he is walking again and ready to leave the hospital. The patient thanks House, but guesses House's personality was still unpleasant before House's leg was injured. The patient gives House his instrument on the condition he never play it. He then asks how many pills House takes. When House says he's in pain, the patient reminds him everyone is.
House sees Foreman, and addresses him by his first name for the first time in an attempt to be more friendly.
A middle-age man comes in for Viagra. House figures out the patient has diabetes and that he has not been managing his condition. He tells him his impotence will go away if he manages his blood sugar. However, he gives him Viagra anyway, while casually mentioning that they may kill him.
Zebra Factor 3/10
Arteriovenous malformations aren't rare, can cause paralysis to the affected area, and are often caused by scarring. It was even part of the differential diagnosis by both Dr. Hamilton and Dr. House.
- Foreman's former boss, Dr. Marty Hamilton comes to PPTH to help oversee the treatment of House's latest patient, John Henry Giles. We learn that Foreman did his residency with Hamilton.
- Foreman is offered a new job by Hamilton but politely declines.
- House and Wilson watch another episode of Prescription Passion.
- As thanks for saving his life, Giles gives House his trumpet as a gift
- This is the first episode with the opening music changed to what it will remain the rest of the series.
Trivia & Cultural References
- Brandy Norwood appears as herself at the start of this episode. Brandy is an actress and R&B singer who has been in show business since she was 14, releasing her first album when she was 15. She has won over 100 awards as a recording artist.
- Wilson uses the term "Rubik's complex" to describe House's obsession with solving riddles. The term refers to the Rubik's Cube, one of the most popular puzzles of all time that was first invented in 1974 and is still one of the best selling games on the market.
- Contrary to this episode's plot, a breathing apparatus is in fact legal in some states. DNR means no measures may be used to bring someone back to life (usually in the form of restarting their heart via CPR). It does NOT always preclude maintaining a patent airway, which is what House did. A separate document called a DNI (Do Not Intubate) may sometimes be needed in a patient's care.
- Cora: "What did you just do?"
- Cameron: "He just saved his life."
- — DNR
- House: "That paralysis thing. Guy can't walk for two years, nobody knows why. It seems mildly interesting."
- Cuddy: "Forget his paralysis."
- House: "Tell that to the rest of his bowling team."
- — DNR
- "Like I always say, there's no 'I' in team. There's a 'me,' though, if you jumble it up."
- House: "My staff are idiots. I'm sure you know what that's like."
- Judge: "Sit down!"
- — DNR
- House: "Medicine is in the pharmacy, patient is immobilized in the I.C.U. It seems like a simple problem of geography."
- Cameron: "Are you asking us to jeopardize our medical licenses for this treatment?"
- — DNR
- House: "There's an error rate, Dr. Hamilton"
- Dr. Hamilton: "And there's a time to let go."
- — DNR
Wilson to House in the court room:
- "Some doctors have a Messiah complex, thinking that they have to save the world. You have a Rubik’s complex..."
House to his team:
- "Yes, his arm is paralyzed; yes, his legs are paralyzed. Why is everyone so gung-ho to connect these two conditions?"
House is trying to put his breathing mask on the patient's mouth.
- ―What are you doing? You can't do this! You can't do this![src]
- John: "So you're telling me that I might not be able to move, but I'll still be able to enjoy a rainbow and be able to tell that life is full of butterflies?"
- House: "Those things are nice."
- — DNR
John to House:
- "You don't risk jail unless you got that one thing, something, anything."
- Dr. Hamilton: "You enjoy working for House?"
- Foreman: "Not the word I'd use."
- — DNR
- Cameron: "What do you want from him? More torment, more hand wringing, him crying to himself to sleep at night?"
- Foreman: "Yes! I want him to show something that says that he's knows, that he actually cares."
- — DNR
- John: "Doc, you just touched my leg."
- House: "What? Are you going to charge me with assault again?"
- John: "No. I felt it."
- — DNR
- House: "We'll take him off everything, and then we'll add one medicine at a time, and when he feels better, we'll have our answer."
- Cameron: "And if he doesn't?"
- House: "Well, then, we're in trouble. Not as much as he is."
- — DNR
House to Foreman as John is getting worse:
- "You still work for me. Come on."
- Hugh Laurie as Gregory House
- Lisa Edelstein as Lisa Cuddy
- Omar Epps as Eric Foreman
- Robert Sean Leonard as James Wilson
- Jennifer Morrison as Allison Cameron
- Jesse Spencer as Robert Chase
- Harry J. Lennix as John Henry Giles
- Chloe Webb as Cora
- Mike Starr as Willie
- Victor Raider-Wexler as Judge Winter
- Rif Hutton as Morris
- Michael Oberlander as Ross
- David Conrad as Marty Hamilton
- Brandy Norwood as Herself
- Clint Baker as Tommy
- Courtney Henggeler as Process Server
- Dennis Howard as Chaplain
- Richard Sinclair as Doctor
- Madison Bauer as Soap Opera Patient
- Deirdre M. Smith as Carol Moffat